EARLY ISLAM:
NEUTRAL TREATIES WITH NON-MUSLIMS
Farrukh I Younus
The history of
Islam is full of accounts where Muslims lived alongside non-Muslims in peace,
with treaties of friendship, fair trade and alliance. Some examples of these
treaties in early Islam are cited below:
-
When Prophet
Muhammad migrated to Medina, and constituted the city-state, he took the
initiative of consolidating Muslim power by entering into alliance with
non-Muslim Arab tribes living around Medina, especially on the caravan
route of the Meccans to and from Syria. The following treaty with a chief
of the Banu Damrah dates from the month of Safar of the year 2 AH:
'He [the Prophet] will not attack Banu Damrah, nor will they attack
him, not swell the troops of his enemies, not help his enemies in any
way' (Ibn Saad, 2/1,3; Aliy al-Qari, Sirah).
Soon afterwards, other
families of the same tribe were rallied and a treaty of mutual aid and
neutrality in particular cases was concluded:
'In the name of Allah
the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. This is the writ of Muhammad, the
Messenger of God, in favour of Banu Damrah, assuring them the security
of their people and their properties; that they may count on his help
if anybody takes aggressive action against them, except in the case of
a fight in the name of religion. This assurance is valid so long as the
sea wets the seashells. Similarly, when the Prophet requires it of them,
they will help him; and they pledge this for God and His Messenger. To
help them will depend upon their loyalty and piety' (Ibn Saad, 1/2, 27;
Suhailiy, Roodh al Anf, II, 58.59).
-
Another tribe
living near the coast of the red-sea was the Banu Ghifar. Their treaty
provided:
'Help is assured to them if anybody attacks them aggressively. If the
Prophet requires their help, they will help him, and it is incumbent upon
them to help him except in wars waged in the name of religion. This is
valid so long as the sea wets the shells' (Ibn Saad, 1/2, 26-27).
-
When the city-state
of Medina was established there were many Jewish tribes who lived in the
eastern suburbs of the city. They also adhered to the city-state and agreed
to, amongst other things:
'If they (the Jews) are called upon to enjoin a peace and adhere to it,
they will do so and adhere to it. Similarly if they ask it, it would be
incumbent upon the Muslims. The war waged in the name of religion are
exempted' (Ibn Hisham, 341-44; Abu Ubaid, Amwal, 517; Ibn Kathir, Bidayah,
III,224-26).
-
In
5 AH the Prophet concluded a treaty of alliance and neutrality with Banu
Abd ibn Adi:
'The Prophet received the deputation of Banu Abd ibn Adi.... They said,
O Muhammad! We are the inhabitants of the Holy Circle (around Mecca) and
we are the mightiest of those who live there. We do not want to fight
you. On the other hand, we are prepared to help you in your expeditions,
except against the Quraish of Mecca. For we do not want to fight against
the Quraish' (Ibn Saad, 1/2, 48).
-
In the treaty
of Hudaibiyah, there is provision for neutrality:
'...And they both agree to put down fighting on the part of the people
for 10 years, during which the people are to enjoy peace and refrain from
fighting each other... And between us is a tied up breast (i.e. we are
bound to the terms of this agreement), and there shall be no secret help
violating neutrality, and no act unfaithfully...' (Supra, XXV, 584).
-
The treaty
with the chief of the province of Raiy:
'...(We will have a peace treaty) Provided that you act in good faith,
serve as a guide to us, do not act faithlessly, and do not secretly help
our enemies in violation of this pledge…' (Tabari, History, 2655).
-
Treaty with
Nubai, concluded by the Muslim governor of Egypt in the time of Caliph
Uthman:
'You, O Nubians, are assured of the protection of God and the Messenger.
That we shall not wage war against you.... But it will not be incumbent
upon the Muslims to drive away any enemy who may encounter you, nor to
prevent him from you, between the limits of the territory of Ulwah and
Aswan' (Maqirziy, Khitat, I, 200).
-
Qais ibn Sad,
the governor of Egypt, addressed the following letter to Caliph Ali, during
the civil wars of the time:
'...I have to inform the commander of the faithful, that there are people
here who want to remain neutral. They have requested me not to take action
against them, but to leave them until the situation clears.'
The Caliph replied: 'Proceed towards the people you have mentioned in
your letter. If they obey as other Muslims, it will be all right, otherwise
punish them.'
The Governor replied, 'I wonder, O Commander of the Faithful, how can
you order me to fight against a people who are keeping away from you and
are giving you a free hand to fight the actual enemy? If you wage war
against them, they shall help the enemies of Islam against Islam. So hear
me, O Commander of the Faithful, and refrain from taking action against
them' (Tabari, History, 3244).
-
In 23 AH when
the Muslims entered Cyprus:
'... the Muslims will not attack the people of Cyprus but at the same
time they (Muslims) will not defend them (Cypriots) if another power attacked
them...' (Tabari, History, 2826).
-
When Fimi
the ruler of Sicily revolted against the Byzantine overlords and appealed
for help to the Muslim governor of Tunisia, the Muslim governor invaded
Sicily in 244 AH and demanded that Fimi and his men remained neutral in
the war, and single-handedly defeated the Byzantines. (Yaqut, Majmu al
Buldan)
May Allah the Almighty
have mercy and guide us to recognizing our own fair and just Muslim heritage!
Source:
Hamidullah, The Muslim Conduct of State, Lahore (Pakistan): Sh. M. Ashraf,
1953, 1961 pp 290-294 (abridged)