Fiqh of the Targets
of Shari`ah
The Fiqh of the Targets of Shari'ah is one of the cornerstones of Civilized
Fiqh on the one hand, the Traditional Fiqh deals with the details and forms
of subsidiary Islamic Laws. On the other hand, Civilized Fiqh deals with
their goals, meanings and interpretations that is to say, the laws and
the ultimate targets for which Allah ordained the laws, obligations, the
lawful, the unlawful and the punishment. Undoubtedly, Allah did not ordain
anything at random, in jest or in vain as those who possess minds say:
"Our
Lord not for naught hast Thou created (all)
this! Glory to Thee."
(3:191)
Among the most magnificent Names of Allah is Al-Hakim, The Ever-Wise which
means that there is wisdom in everything He has created or ordered regardless
of our knowledge or ignorance of it. He is Ever-Wise in every thing that
He ordained and destined.
The Qur'an goes so far so as to state the purpose and message of the worship
rites, when Allah says that: "Prayer refrains from
shameful and evil deeds" (29:45)
Zakah is meant to: "Purify and sanctify them." (9:103)
Fasting: "That ye may learn self-restrain." (2:183)
And Pilgrimage:
"That they may witness the benefits (provided)
for them, and celebrate the Name of Allah."
(22:28) The Sunnah emphasized the importance of the purpose and message of these
rites. If these goats are not achieved, these rites will turn into superficial
and empty rites and the Muslim who performs worship rites without adhering
to their purpose and message, will be denied the reward of his worship.
Many Hadiths stress this meaning; Abu Hurairah narrated
the Prophet (Peace be upon him) said: "Whoever
does not give up false statements (i.e., telling lies), and
evil deeds, and speaking bad words to others, Allah is not in need of his
(Fasting) leaving
his food and drink." [Note: Reported by Al-Bukhari on
the authority of Abu Hurairah in the Book of Fasting (Sawm)] "Perhaps, a man who fasts in this world may come out with nothing more
than hunger from his Fasting whereas, perhaps a man who gets up for Tahajjud
Prayer in this world may come out with nothing more than staying up all
night from his Tahajjud." [Note:
Reported by lbn Majah on the authority of Abu Hurairah, Sahih Al-Jami'
Al- Saghir (3488)]
Since worship rites have moral and social purposes and messages besides
their spiritual aims, then it is only natural that all the Islamic Laws
have their respective messages particularly the ones that deal with family,
community and state affairs.
Some of these targets are stated quite clearly in the Qur'an and Sunnah
preceded by the familiar conjunctions. One of these targets is the induction
of subsidiary laws. Moreover, there are subsidiary as well as general collective
targets for some of these laws. For instance justice is a general target,
in fact, it is the target of all Divine messages as the Qur'an states: "We sent aforetime Our messengers with Clear Signs
and sent down with them the Book and Balance (of right and wrong),
that men may stand forth injustice." (57:25)
Sufficiency and security are general targets. Allah bestowed on Quraish
and ordered them to worship Him as a sign of their thankfulness when He
says: "So let them worship the Lord of this House,
Who provides them with food against hunger, and with security." (106:3-4)
The division of the spoils of war that Allah bestowed on Muslims, among
people is a general target. Therefore the Qur'an explained the reason for
the distribution of the spoils by the Prophet among the weak, orphans,
needy and the wayfarers by saying: "In order that
it may not (merely) make a circuit between
the wealthy among you." (59:7)
Jurists maintained that the targets of Shari `ah are general and diverse.
These targets are spiritual or, in other words, religious. The first target
of Shari `ah is the survival of religion whether in creed or worship because
religion is the essence and spirit of life. Moreover, they are moral targets, which are stated in the verse that order
Muslim to perform major worship, and in the hadith of the Prophet:
"I was sent to perfect the noblest of virtues." [Note:
Reported by lbn Sa'd and Al-Bukhari in Al-Adab Al-Mufard, and also by Al-Hakim
and Al-Baihaqi after Abu Hurairah in Al-Shu'ab as mentioned in Sahih Al-Jami AI-Saghir]
For virtue is inseparable from religion.
They are human targets as it preserves the sanctity of man's blood, money,
honor, mind, dignity, and freedom. They are economical targets for it places
money among the necessary needs that must be protected in every possible
way.
Finally, they are future targets for it does not only takes care of man
in the present but also in the future time as it places reproductive health
among its essential interacts.
A.
The Companions` Adherence to the Targets of Shari`ah:
Whoever ponders the Fiqh of the Companions, will soon realize that they
preceded the nation in grasping the precepts of the Fiqh of the Targets
of Shari`ah. They bore it in mind in their Fatwas - juristic judgments
- jurisdiction and teaching. For instance, `Umar refrained from distributing the spoils of a rural area
of Iraq caring about the succeeding generations of the Muslim Nation arguing:
"If
it is not for my concern for the future generations of Muslims, I would
have distributed the spoils of every village I conquer among those who
participated in its conquest as the Prophet did in Khaibar." [Note:
Reported by Al-Bukhari in the Book or Al-Maghazi Al-Mudhana`h and AI-Khums]
Similarly, `Uthman has allowed catching the astray camels, in contrary
to the custom of the Prophet's (Peace be upon him) time due to change in
people's mores and circumstances that imposed new attitude. Moreover, he
ordered the Second Adhan of the Friday Prayer outside the Mosque so as
to call Muslims to the Prayer time as the boundaries of Medina extended
and the need necessitated this procedure.
`Ali, as another example, gave a guarantee to pay the debts of the manufacturers. The Successors, in the same course, said that pricing of goods is allowed
when necessity arises although the Prophet (Peace be upon him) abstained
from it in his time saying, "Allah is the One Who
determines the price and He is the Restrainer (Al-Qabid) and
the Outspreader (Al-Basit)." [Note:
Reported by Abu Dawud on the authority of Anas in the Book of Al Buyu`
(3451) and also reported by Ahmad. Al-Tirmidhi, lbn Majah, lbn Kibban and Al-Baihaqi, Sahih
Al-Jami Al-Saghir.]
A group of jurists agreed that it is allowed. Sheikh of Islam Ibn Taymiyah
in his book Al-Hisbah and Ibn Al-Qaiyim in his book (Al-Tunuq Al-Hukmiy'ah)
said that its being allowed is most probable.
The research scholars of the Four Schools all agreed on this glorious golden
rule namely, the Fatwa (Legal Ruling) changes in respect of time, place,
circumstances, and custom. They feared that a group of scholars may cling
to certain statements said at a certain time under certain circumstances,
notwithstanding the fact that they could no longer meet the targets of
Shari'ah due to the change of time, place and people.
I have proven the authenticity of this rule guided by proofs from the Qur'an,
Sunnah and the history of the Companions in my book "The Factors of Collectiveness
and flexibility in Islamic Shari`ah". For instance, Ibn Al-Qajyim, the research scholar, wrote at the beginning
of his useful chapter about (Change of Fatwa) in his book (I'lam Al-Mawaqi'n)
and stressed the fact that the Shari'ah in its basis for judgment, concerns
people and life. For the Shari`ah is just, merciful, useful and wise. Every
judgment that deviates from justice to oppression, from mercy to ruthlessness,
from usefulness to corruption, and from wisdom to folly, notwithstanding
the different interpretations of it, is definitely not Shari `ah-oriented. [Note:
See I`lam Al-Muwaq'in, vol.3,
p.14, Al-Sa'dah]
One the great afflictions that appeared on the Islamic area is a group
of people who do not have any idea concerning the Fiqh of Targets. They
offer a golden opportunity for the secularists and prowesterners to attack
Islam. Moreover, they stigmatize the straight Islamic thought and the constructive
Islamic activity, they are captivated by the words and form. I called them
"The New Group of Zahiriyyah", although they are not well-learned or cultured
as the old group of Zahiriyyah were in fact, they did not take anything
from Ibn Hazm, the most erudite of Al-Zahiriyyah, but his occasional inflexibility
and rudeness. They read some of the masterpieces of the two Imams: Ibn Taymiyyah and
Ibn Al-Qayim, but unfortunately, they misinterpret them and failed to understood
their message. Moreover they neither followed in the footsteps of the two
Sheikhs, nor those who followed them. Instead, they indulged in imitating
some of the contemporary thinkers and followed their to the letter. As
a result, we heard about some people who call for abandoning the Zakah
on (banknotes) and claim that the prohibition of usury does not apply on
banknotes! They seemed to have overlooked the fact that banknotes are the
coins of our time, the basis of transitions and exchange, and core of property.
Other people called for abolishing the Zakah of merchandise imposed on
traders, claiming that there are no authentic hadith concerning its being
obligatory. They seemed to have, voluntarily or involuntarily forgotten
that the evidences of its being obligatory in both the Qur'an and Sunnah.
Moreover, there are the targets of Shari`ah, the narrations of the Companions
which majority of jurists upheld as consensus. [Note:
See my refutation of this statement with legal proofs in my book (The Primary
Recourse is to the Qur'an and Sunnah) (Al-Marji'yah Al-`uliyah Lil Qur'an
Wa Al-Sunnah), chapter of (Understanding Specific Texts in the Light of
General Texts) In addition to this, some people make a great commotion about dropping
the paying of equivalent value as a Zakatul Fitr just although `Umar Ibn
`Abdel-'Aziz, Abu Hanifah and his followers and a group of the late scholars
of the Nation have have upheld it. [Note:
See the proofs of this opinion in our book (Fiqh Al-zakah) vol.2, p. 952,
956, published by Maktabat Wahbah, and my book (Kaifa Nat'amal Ma' AI-Sunnah)
(How to Behave Towards the Sunnah ) p. 135, 137] Yet this equivalent value payment of Zakatul-Fitr, the best way to pay
Zakatul-Fitr in the big cities such as Cairo.
Therefore, we can, safely presume that many of this group of people are
sincere servants of Allah yet they, simply, do not have adequate knowledge
concerning the Fiqh of Targets. Being sincere is not enough to survive
and support the religion of the Nation.
The Kharijites were also sincere servants of Allah, as Imam Ahmad narrated
in many authentic Hadiths which praise them. For instance "Their perfection
of worship rites in Prayer (Tahajiud) and recitation of Qur'an is incomparable
with anyone else. Yet their vulnerability lies in their mentality and superficial
understanding of Fiqh. The Prophet (Peace be upon him) described them as
the people who: "Do not go beyond sounds, syllables.
and vowels in their understanding of Quran." Consequently, they did not grasp the deep meaning of the Qur'an and were
not able to reveal its mysteries, thus they were described as a group that:
"Killing
the people of Islam, and leaving those who worship idols unbothered." [Note:
Agreed upon on the authority of Abu Sa'id Al-Khudri Al-Lu `Lu Marjan (639)]
B.
Protection of Interests:
The Shari'ah seeks to protect and maximize the interests on the one hand
and to prevent and minimize corruption on the other hand. It also allows
good and useful things, forbids evil and harmful things, eases the effort
of Allah's slaves and lessen the difficulty that they might encounter.
Allah says: "And has imposed no difficulty on you in
religion." (22:78) "Allah intends every facility for you; He does not
want to put you to difficulties." (2:185) Also, the Prophet states:
"No
harm is inflicted or reciprocated in Islam." [Note:
Reported by lbn Majah and it is
a Sound hadith]
The Companions, the most well-learned in Shari'ah, exerted their utmost
effort to meet its targets and message.
Therefore, they often acted according to what is best and what comes within
the interest of Muslims.
Firstly, Abu Bakr had the interest of Muslims
in mind, when he ordered togather the scrolls, on which the Qur'an was
written, so as to compile them into one book. This was a thing that the
Prophet himself (Peace be upon him) did not do, yet Abu Bakr thought it
over, then decided to act upon `Umar's advice because it aimed at doing
what was in the best interest of Islam.
Secondly, he also had the best interest of Muslims in mind
when he chose `Umar as his successor in the Caliphate after his death,
notwithstanding the fact that the Prophet himself did not nominate a successor.
Thirdly, when `Umar took over the Caliphate, he had the best interest
of Muslims in mind when he enacted the system of Khiraj (taxes paid on
the newly conquered lands), registered the numbers of the armed forces
and the needy people in accounts and books of the treasury, built cities,
establish prisons, used various ways of punishing evil doers through Ta'zir
(punishments lesser than Hadd) e.g. spilling mixed-with-water milk, and
confiscated the money of the governors who trade while in post.
Fourthly, `Uthman too had the best interest of Muslims in
mind when he compiled the Qur'an into one Book, spread copies of it everywhere
and burnt unauthorized copies. moreover, he gave an order to allow the
divorced woman to inheriting deceased husband if he divorced her on his
deathbed to deprive her of inheritance.
Fifthly, `Ali had the best interest of Muslims in mind when he gave
an order to Abu Al-'Aswad AI-Du'ali to write down the basics of Arabic
grammar, and issued a decree that manufacturers must guarantee to repay
the amounts of lost money which people have given them in order to invest,
if they did not prove that they were not, in any way, responsible for this
loss. Later, `Uthman commented: "This decree will make people stand stead
fast." [Note:
See "Tanqih Al-Fusoul" and its explanation by Al-Qarafi, p.198, 199, and
"Masader Al-Tashri Fima La Nassa Fihi"," Sources of Lgislation in Matters
About Which There Are No texts Available" by Knallaf p.85, 88]
Sixthly, Mu' adh Ibn Jabal had this interest in mind when he took
Yemeni textiles instead of the Zakah on plants and fruit saying: "I will
take Khamis and Labis - local textiles- instead of the actual plants and
fruit for this will ease things for you and will be more useful to the
poor in Medina." [Note:
See our book "Fiqh Al-Zakah", vol.2, p.810. published by Maktabat
Wahbah, No.16]
Abu Hanifah agreed to `Uthman's opinion. Ibn Taymiyah, the Sheik of Islam,
and AI-Bukhari recommend these actions on condition that they are in the
best interest of Muslims.
Seventhly, Mu'awiyah had this interest in mind when he took half
of a Sa' (approximately 1.50 Kilogram) of wheat instead of one Sa' (approximately
3 Kilograms) of dates as Zakatul-Fitr. The Companions at that time, agreed
to what he did except Abu Sa'id AI-Khudri (May Allah be pleased with both) [Note:
"Fiqh Al- Zakah", vol.2, p.932
and pages following it]
This interest was always there. It made those who followed the Rightly
Guided Caliphs establish mail service, use Arabic in the accounts of the
treasury, establish the mint and attend to the rest of the state affairs
without objection from the scholars of the Muslim Nation.
Also it made Imam Abu Hanifah adopt the opinion that the Mufti, ignorant
doctors, and bankrupt building contractors must all be announced as legally
incompetent, not with standing the fact that his School (May Allah be pleased
with him) does not approve of announcing the legal incompetence of the
sane adults even if they were dissolute, out of respect to them as human
beings. He announced the legal incompetence of them lest they should harm people.
[Note: See "Al-Ikhtiyar", vol. 4,
p.92] In addition, the Maliki School of thought and others issued a Fatwa allowing
the imposition of taxes for those who could afford it, in case that there
was insufficient money in the treasury (Bait AI-Mal) and there was the
necessity of collecting money so as to keep the possession of certain properties.
AI-Ghazali in "Al-Mustasfii" and Al-Shatibi in " All'tisam" and others
supported his opinion. [Note: Fiqh
Al-Zakah, vol.2, p.986, 987]
Also, the majority of scholars allowed the killing of a Muslim, if the
disbelievers took him as a shield and there was no other choice but to
fight there. [Note:
See, Al-Ghazali, Al-Mustasfa, vol. I, p.294, 295, also, "Al- ikhtiyar Lita'lil
Al-Mukhtar", vol.4, p. 119, published by Halab, and "Matalib `uli Al-Nuha",
vol.2, p. 518, 519]
The Scholars of Hanafi, Shafi'i, a group of Maliki and Hanbali Juristic
Schools allowed the performance of a Cesarean operation to save the life
of the fetus if the mother had died and if the trustworthy physicians were
of the opinion that he is alive notwithstanding the lawful inviolability
of the dead. A group of scholars are of the opinion that it is obligatory
because it means saving the life of someone by cutting a part of the body
of a dead person. The author of "Al-Muhadhab" of the Shafi'i School likened
this to eating dead meat at the time of famine. [Note:
See "Al-Muhadhab" and its explanation (Al-Majmu'), vol.5, p.301, 302, and
also "Hashiyyat Al-Sawi", vol.1, p.205] For if it was a matter of choice then the interest of a living person is
far more important than respecting the dead. Similarly, the interest of
saving the life of a fetus is a first priority and violating the sanctity
of his dead mother is of a secondary importance. Thus, the physicians'
choice adhered to the rule of choosing the less harmful and more beneficial
measure.
|